Is Death Bad for the One Who Dies?

Free Will Identity and the Self · Open board

The self as a chain of connected moments, a ship rebuilt plank by plank. This lesson asks what happens at the end of the chain, and whether that end can be bad for the person whose chain it is, given that they are not there to feel it.

Before you start. Free Will, Identity & the Self asked what makes you the same person over time, and settled on a chain of memories and character that thins out over the years, with no single hidden “you” underneath. This lesson takes that chain and asks two calmer, older questions about it: is its ending a harm to you, and what makes the stretch before the ending go well?

The idea in 30 seconds

One ancient argument says death cannot be bad for you, because a harm needs someone to feel it, and when death is present you are not.
The main modern reply says death is bad by what it takes away: the good years you would have lived, which is why dying young seems worse than dying old.
A second ancient argument compares the time after death with the time before birth, which nobody fears, and asks why the two should be treated differently.
A thought experiment about a machine that can fake any experience suggests most people want a life that is real, not only one that feels good.
The absurd is the clash between how seriously we take our lives and how small they look from far enough away; one well-known response is to live fully anyway.

Read the story · Skip to the numbers